I am in shock! I am a makeup junkie, love trying Chanel, Laura Mercier, Lancôme, Tarte, Fenty… all of it. This eyeliner is better than the Laura Mercier cake liner. It absolutely stays in the upper tightline and doesn’t spread to my crease when wearing on my lash line! Absolutely recommend. Previously used Tattoo Liner from KVD but this has my heart.